The historical influence of liberalism on the nineteenth-century pontifical magisterium on religious freedom: continuity or break with the Second Vatican Council?


  • Jorge Salinas Mengual Catholic University of Murcia (Spain)


Gregory XVI, Pius IX, Leo XIII, religius freedom, liberalism


The right to religious freedom has been the object of an historical evolution in the definition of its content, which has not only been affected by the relations between temporal and spiritual power, but also by the influence of ideologies that have tried to circumscribe religion to the merely private field, in an attempt to build a new society that identifies the progress of man in the development of science and in neglecting God. One of these ideologies, liberalism, has had a very important role in the definition of the guidelines of the right to religious freedom by the Magisterium of the Church. This article analyses the modality in which the following three Popes of the 19th century interpreted this right: Gregory XVI, Pius IX and Leo XIII; it analyses the aspects on which they put more attention, the extent to which liberalism influenced the development of their theory on this topic and the extent to which we can talk about continuity or rupture in the history of the ecclesial Magisterium in relation to the definition of the right to religious freedom, especially in the context of the Declaration Dignitatis humanae of the Second Vatican Council.


Keywords: Gregory XVI; Pius IX; Leo XIII; religious freedom; liberalism.


AA.VV. La libertad religiosa. Bilbao, 1970.

Aubert, Robert. Ensayos sobre libertad religiosa. Barcelona, 1967.

D’Avack, Pietro Agostino. “La libertad religiosa en el Magisterio actual de la Iglesia católica.” Ius Canonicum, 10.5 (1965): 367-368.

De La Hera, Alberto., and Soler, Carlos. Tratado de Derecho Eclesiástico. Pamplona, 1994.

Del Pozo Abejón, Gerardo.  La Iglesia y la libertad religiosa. Madrid, 2007. 

Díez Alegría, José María. “La libertad religiosa en el despliegue histórico de la doctrina de la Iglesia.”  Vaticano II. La libertad religiosa. Textos y análisis. Madrid (1966): 518-522.

Madrigal Terrazas, Santiago. Joseph Ratzinger, de teólogo a Papa. Madrid, 2009. 

Martínez, Jose Luis. Libertad religiosa y dignidad humana. Claves católicas de una gran conexión. Madrid, 2009.

Murray, John Courtney. “Hacia una inteligencia del desarrollo de la doctrina de la Iglesia sobre libertad religiosa.” La libertad religiosa. Madrid (1969): 143-144.

Pavan, Pietro. La libertad religiosa y los poderes públicos. Madrid, 1966. 

Pena González, Miguel Anxo. León XIII y su tiempo. Salamanca, 2004.

Torres Rojas, Enrique. La libertad religiosa en León XIII y en el Concilio Vaticano II. Vitoria, 1968.

Rhonheimer, Martin. “La doctrina del Concilio sobre la libertad religiosa. Una interpretación a la luz de la hermenéutica de la reforma de Benedicto XVI.” En torno al Vaticano II: claves históricas, doctrinales y pastorales. Eds. Aranda, A., Lluch, M., and Herrera. 171-189.




How to Cite

Salinas Mengual, J. (2019). The historical influence of liberalism on the nineteenth-century pontifical magisterium on religious freedom: continuity or break with the Second Vatican Council?. Vergentis. Revista De Investigación De La Cátedra Internacional Conjunta Inocencio III, 1(8), 293–321. Retrieved from